
It was a movie date last night. The last movie I saw in the theatre was the Christmas Carol in 3D Imax. I was crying and burying my face into my boyfriend’s shoulder at the scary parts with every other 8-year-old in the crowd. What can I say? I have a sensitivity to the depiction of evil.
I put that out there because I have not been a big fan of Tim Burton in the past. No moral, ethical reason—more for stylistic or aesthetic reasons. So, I was skeptical and was very ready to bury my head once again in Michael’s shoulder. Except we arrived and there were only single seats left. So, I would have to go it alone.
(On to the movie…) Friends, this movie was poignant for me. It is the theatrical articulation of much of what I have been studying for my research paper. The movie begins with a party that Alice Kingsley and her mother walk into. We find out it is to be Alice’s engagement party. Tim Burton so beautifully illustrated the immensity of what that moment would have felt like to a young woman. All the expectations, all the choking ties, and restraining corsets (that she refused to wear, I’ll add).
Where is choice? Where is the space to see your own face, your own desires and thoughts in a sea of faces of people who have all conformed and expect you to do the same? All the presuppositions these people look at you with, ready to drape you—nay, drown you with.
It is a part of growing up, right? Her pretty face won’t last forever. As an adult you see that choice is an illusion, a childish dream when there are responsibilities and expectations. And because there is no other place to go, Alice runs off towards that sliver of hope: the illusion.
So, Alice falls into a hole in the earth and lands in Underland, where impossibilities are daily realities.
From here on out, I will attempt to quickly (or not so quickly) touch upon a few themes…
1. Presuppositions. Conformity is expected and nearly forced upon her, but there is enough of a voice inside Alice to steal her away for the hope of something more…more Alice. As children, we assume everything is as it must be—is as it has always been. For Alice to see, in the sea of faces, a talking rabbit with a clock!?!? It is her hope against the loss of her self. That little rabbit hole she chases and falls into is the narrow path of her salvation. (Amen)
2. Creativity. Oh, the imagination of a child! We see it as clear as day in this story. Creativity is squelched in Alice. Conformity kills creativity. To accept that things are as they should be prevents us from imagining what they could be. And this is the surrendering of Eden—the surrendering of a better future, of a life beyond what we know.
3. Choice. Several times in the movie, this theme arises, not so subtly (which I like). We are given the contrast between the engagement scene and the illusion of choice and the scene in which she can choose to be the “champion” for the white queen. The queen asks for a champion, not even looking at Alice. Everyone eventually looks to her, and the queen tells her, “It is your choice, Alice. It must be. For if you choose to go, you will…go…alone.” Alice runs off in tears. She is torn. She sees that all these people want her to be someone she does not believe she is. In this moment of despair, I see the emasculated Alice—the polite, soft, pretty girl she is bred to be—fight with the championess. It is a dual of self-esteem, of realities, of truths. Who am I? And what is my choice?
4. Voice & Identity. From the moment she meets all the characters in Underland, it is a question of, “Is this the Alice? The Alice who is foretold to kill the Jabberwocky?” Alice is convinced that she is not that Alice. The blue caterpillar who meets her the beginning of her journey responds, “You are not hardly her.” At the moment of deciding whether she would step up as a champion, she meets the caterpillar again, who says, “Alice, (sigh) at last.” This entire journey through Underland is a journey of freeing up her mind, her self, and emboldening her voice. And when she returns to London, into the moment of her engagement party, she definitely has a voice (chuckle chuckle).
5. Dream & Reality. Alice keeps on telling herself this is just a dream. I can wake up at any moment. I cannot be hurt. And this becomes an excuse—that “rational” voice interrupting the journey of finding herself. Once she accepts and understands that Underland is a place of real emotions and relationships, of impossibilities made possible, she sees that it is worth facing her fear. As she battles the dragon, she counts through what she knows as true: the 6 impossible things, she has found possible. I loved this! It is speaking truth to the self for the sake of life. Alice has found her own truth and remembers, recounts these truths as she battles the Jabberwocky. This is so beautiful because these memories, this act of remembering empowers her and gives her that last bit of courage to step fully into her “calling”. Counting your truths and remembering them is powerful in the face of fear or oppression.
So, go see the movie and if your journey to self has been similar to mine, maybe you’ll be crying as Alice battles the Jabberwocky—not because it shouldn’t die, but because….well….it is Alice, at last.